republished with expressed consent Rev. Kim M. Cran, Senior Pastor, 2009Dear Members and Friends of Boise First UCC, I greatly enjoy the privilege of conducting wedding ceremonies. From the initial conversation when couples share with me their desire to marry, through our discussions about their hopes and dream, joys and sorrows(including their plans for the ceremony), on through the joy of the day itself and the blessing of watching them grow together as a couple – weddings are a high point of pastoral ministry. In my sixteen years of ordained ministry, I have officiated at over three hundred weddings. In this regard, I have been truly blessed.
Since my arrival in Idaho, one area that has not been a blessing is the pain and difficulties that lgbt couplesshare with me regarding the process of being a couple in Idaho. There is no legal marriage ceremony for gay couples, nor are legal marriage ceremonies that are conducted in other states recognized by our state. There is no legal protection against discrimination against gay couples, and spousal benefits, when available, are rare. I was stunned to learn of the legal expense gay couples must endure in order to try to secure a fraction of the rights straight couples enjoy just by having a marriage license. The stories I have heard and the struggles I have witnessed bring tears to my eyes and anger to my heart. This is discrimination, and it is wrong!
Hearing and witnessing the discrimination our lgbt congregants and friends experience as they faithfully live out their marriage vows leaves me with a serious ethical and pastoral dilemma; I believe it is wrong for me to provide a service (signing marriage licenses) for one group of congregants and friends that I cannot provide for all members of our community. When I sign marriage licenses for some, I participate in the very process that actively excludes others.
I am certainly not the only UCC minister to feel this way. For many years, our denomination, both at the national and conference level, has spoken out against this form of discrimination. Many ministers throughout the UCC have, as an act of conscience and justice, refused to sign marriage licenses until they could sign them for all couples. Within our own Conference, the ministers of the Ashland Congregation has taken the step of refusing to sign marriage licenses until the discrimination against gay couples is ended. This decision was overwhelmingly supported by our Conference and our sister churches.
I shared this ethical and pastoral dilemma with our Church Council at our meeting in June, and asked Council to reflect on and pray about this situation. We shared a good discussion at this meeting, and agreed to talk about it again in August.
At the Council Meeting in August, I shared with our leadership team that, upon careful reflection and prayerful consideration, I felt I could no longer participate in signing marriage licenses for some until I could sign them for all. Following some discussion, I was delighted to receive the unanimous support of Council for my decision.

Therefore, as a matter of conscience and justice, I will not sign another marriage license until I can do so for all couples who come to the church seeking a wedding ceremony. I will continue to enthusiastically work with all couples who wish to have me preside at their religious wedding ceremony. However, in the case of straight couples, they will have to make other arrangements for the signing of their marriage license (and can do so through the office that issues their license). This will mean an additional step, and some inconvenience, for straight couples. But I would hope that any couple who would choose to affiliate with this church would understand our commitment to justice and equality, and would welcome this additional step as a way of standing for justice.
If you have any questions, please feel free to speak with me about this matter. May the day come soon when this and all forms of discrimination end, and all of our congregants and friends have access to the blessing of both the church and the state on their loving, committed relationships.
Faithfully yours,
Rev. Kim M. Cran, Senior Pastor
Labels: Boise First United Church of Christ, Gay Marriage, Kim M. Cran, open and affriming churches in Boise Idaho